Vol. 4, Issue 5 May 2012
 
The Lede
On the Job
Foundations
Expressions
Sweet Ache
Letters From
Brazil, Jordan
Perspectives
Politics
A Paradigm Trap
Culture
Direct Message
Reporting & Essays
Reportage
The Takeover
Profile
The Outlier
Arts & Reviews
Art Review
The Revolution Will Be Sung
Art Review
Others Like Us
Books
Review
Light Show
Review
With Souls and Elbows
Editor's Notebook
Finally, A Principled Stand

Journeys


 

Journeys

Off the Grid
A journey into the world of Karachi’s population of Afghan refugees
Published :1 February 2011
Text Size  
Print this page
Add to favourites
   
Single page
BULLIT MARQUEZ / AP PHOTO
Afghan refugees, who crossed the Pakistani border, arrive in Shakirpur, Pakistan, on 13 October 2001.
A S I DRIVE PAST the Pakistan Air Force dormitories, whizzing past the busy roads leading to Karachi’s Jinnah International Airport, airplanes hover above like bloated mosquitoes in the clear February morning; below them, crows and mynah birds also seem to float calmly in the colourless sky. The first sign that one has landed in Karachi is a giant
fluorescent-yellow McDonald’s sign just outside the airport; here, it is the golden arches that greet newly arrived travellers—rather than a flag, a welcome sign or the gleaming visage of some ghastly local politician.

After passing the airport, leaving behind its security officers wearing bullet-proof vests and helmets, things begin to look desolate. Driving away from the hustle and bustle of Karachi proper, the roads begin to seem wider even though they’re not; there are just fewer cars on them. I pass a spate of schools, all in gaudy residential bungalows, their names painted across their gates and balconies: My Little World School, White House Grammar School, Middle East Middle School. On the left-hand side of the road, there is a wasteland; on the right, more learning centres, with names like ‘Little Hearts Grammar School (Parsi Administration).’

But the wasteland will not remain barren for long: a massive golf club, resort and spectacular getaway for the rich is being built on the recently levelled land. Billboards mark the boundaries of the luxury retreat, depicting Arab-looking businessmen grinning at Western-style houses, confident golfers resembling a pre-scandal Tiger Woods, and glittering glass lobbies staffed by legions of secretaries, all of whom will be stomping through this dry land, with its wild shrubs and rocky soil, soon enough.

AMEAN J/18% GREY

A blackboard at the Hasan Islamia Public School, which teaches Afghan refugees in English and Urdu mediums.
I pass by Gulistan-e-Jauhar, by more army bases, by land that has reportedly been bought by the Aga Khan Foundation, and by even more army-owned land, which the businessmen-in-uniform plan to transform into extensions of the existing Defence Housing Authority schemes that have already expanded throughout the city.

At a toll plaza, I pay a small note to the man sitting in the window. Another man, in a gray shalwar kameez, strolls between the stalled cars selling oranges and small apples in plastic shopping bags, shouting out prices to the truck drivers. There are a lot of trucks now: this is Karachi’s transport hub, where violence had recently erupted between the Pathans who control the transport in the Sohrab Goth suburb that links Karachi to the rest of the country and the Urdu-speaking Muhajirs who seek to relieve them of their power—shootings and riots and killings. Today, it’s quiet.

I see a large truck, filled with timber and painted in the vibrant Pakistani style, with splashes of bright colour everywhere; bright green decals plastered across the mud flaps say “dekh magar payar se”—“look, but with love”—a popular transport vehicle flirt. This bus has unicorns dancing in a Kashimiri landscape, icy mountains and flowing rivers, with a portrait of General Musharraf posed in the middle. It takes me a minute to make out the general; he’s painted with such soft-focus adoration that he looks more like an aged Korean granny—smooth skin and bouffant hair, even with the epaulettes.

After a series of forks in the road—heading to Hyderabad, Lasbela and Hub in Balochistan—I continue on toward Sohrab Goth. But there is no way to know where I am really going. A map of Karachi, produced by Haqqi Brothers and bought at the city’s teeming Urdu Bazaar, is laid out on my desk at home. The map is a big mess of blue, pink, purple and orange districts and dots. It tells me that my destination, the Afghan Muhajir Refugee Camp, is not in Sohrab Goth—which is not even on the map—but in Gadap Town, somewhere near the Dreamworld Resort Hotel & Golf Club and the Cosy Water Park. (The map, however, also says, in small print at the bottom of the Arabian Sea, “Information at the map are [sic] not authentic.”) According to another map I’ve bought, which only confuses me further, the refugee camp appears to be either in Gulshan-e-Maymar or Gulshan-e-Mehran. It’s huddled between the crossfires of what the map identifies as a ‘principal road’ and a ‘main road.’ I’m not sure what the difference is, or if, in fact, there is any difference. It’s in North Karachi, no one disagrees there. But its actual location is unimportant: there are no buses that travel to the Afghan Muhajir Refugee Camp; for all intents and purposes, it is entirely off the grid. These are the sticks. This is not a town.

Upon entering the camp, you are met by one-room mud stores, stacked high with empty glass bottles of Mirinda and 7-Up warming under the midday sun. They will be recycled for a pittance and then used again without being washed. The bottles are dirty as only glass can be, scratched and cloudy where repeated use has marked them. There are posters of Indian film actresses and health pamphlets from the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) on tuberculosis and polio taped to the walls, but again, there is something old and used about this decorative wallpaper.

I WAS BORN IN KABUL, and I am, if only through blood ties—not by love or the constancy of family—half-Afghan. Being Afghan in this way, Afghan-born or half-Afghan, as though it is a condition, has always felt complicated to me: it means that my interest in and attention to the country of my birth was not decided for me.

I have chosen to be connected to this particular condition in part because of the suffering I can see among the Afghan refugees all around me in my city, in my Karachi; because of the friendliness, because of something mountainous and something destroyed about all the Afghans whom I have met at conferences and textile bazaars and electronics markets and airport terminals. There is a pride, now somewhat fractured, that I gravitate toward; it is the same sort of wounded confidence that comes to the surface when I correct people who presume that I was born in Pakistan.

I have an open heart, I confess. I’m from a lot of places, and I leave myself in suitcases and airports and border places.

AMEAN J/18% GREY

A student at Hasan Islamia Public School in Karachi.
According to the UNHCR, for the past two decades Pakistan has been home to the largest refugee population in the world. Afghans who fled their homes after the Soviet invasion in 1979—and the American-and Saudi-backed civil war that quickly followed—settled in Pakistan and Iran. By 1988, according to a New York Times article written that year, some 3.3 million Afghans were living in Pakistan. Another two million had settled in Iran—perhaps an easier place to adjust to, given the connection between Dari and Persian, and yet a crueller host to its linguistically familiar refugees.

Afghans in Iran are forced to work below the radar, thanks to laws that make it difficult for them to legally hold jobs; and the country’s recent high levels of unemployment have made it increasingly hard to find labour even in the black market. Low-paid construction work and under-the-table odd-jobs are no longer a safe bet for those without identity cards—and the refugees will never get identity cards; they are treated like ghosts, as shadows of people. When I was in Tehran three years ago, the only Afghans I noticed were little boys selling chewing gum and hard candy for pennies off wooden slabs tied around their necks.

After 11 September 2001 and the American invasion of Afghanistan, another wave of refugees fled from the rubble. The number of Afghans in Pakistan swelled to five million— including those who had been born here to refugees who came after 1979.

AMEAN J/18% GREY

The school, based at Afghan Muhajir Refugee Camp, offers education to 190 students.
The refugees in Pakistan live in camps—in actual camps. Before it was closed in 2002, the Jalozai camp in the North-West Frontier Province (NWFP), one of the largest in the country, resembled a plastic city: tens of thousands of Afghans lived in tents made from garbage bin liners or thin plastic sheets. Jemima Khan, the author and journalist who brought the world’s attention to the squalor of Jalozai, wrote this about her first visit to the camp: “At first sight, the camp resembles a vast dumping ground. Thousands of aimless people are wandering between endless rows of miniature makeshift plastic tents, one next to the other with no space between them…children barefoot and in rags are everywhere…the few latrines that do exist have not been dug deep enough and are overflowing, running in filthy streams through the camp and into tents.” Jalozai, a UNHCR official told Khan, was “fast turning into a death camp,” so dire was the condition of its refugees.

In the summer of 2007, I visited one of the largest Afghan refugee camps in Peshawar, Kacha Garhi. At the time, the camp was home to more than 100,000 refugees—and it was a week away from being shut down. The Pakistani government, assisted by the UNHCR, had been pushing for repatriation since 2002, trying to uproot the refugees who had only just escaped a fresh round of war and occupation. In 2005, Pakistan began a registration process by which Proof of Registration (PoR) cards were issued to about 2.15 million refugees over the next two years. In Iran, meanwhile, the official number of Afghan refugees dwindled to under a million as repatriation programs were pursued in earnest, a move that caused the Afghan parliament to write an open letter to the Iranian state asking the government to halt their deportation drive until the worst of the winter had passed.

The mud homes in Kacha Garhi each housed an average of 20 people. I myself saw 11 people file out of one house myself, walking sideways in alleys that were too cramped to allow more than one person through their dusty corridors. Garbage and open, festering sewers were everywhere. Bulldozers were already in action, razing parts of the camp to the ground. Three years later, Kacha Garhi has come back into action as a refugee camp, but now it houses Pakistan’s own internally displaced, refugees from the army’s wars in Swat and Waziristan.

In 2007, Pakistan began seriously pursuing repatriation. According to the UNHCR, 350,000 Afghan refugees were repatriated between the spring and winter of that year, each armed with a generous 100-dollar stipend—though in Katcha Garhi, I was told the real figure was closer to 60 dollars. Many in Pakistan claim that that families took the money, crossed the border, gave the cash to friends or relatives still stuck in Afghanistan, and then turned around and returned to Pakistan. Or that they come and go between the two countries, leaving when danger strikes either soil and returning when safety is assured. The official numbers are dubious at best: according to the UNHCR, 80 percent of the Afghan refugees in the NWFP were repatriated in 2007—though only three percent of those in Sindh returned home—leaving two million refugees in Pakistan. As of March 2009, the UNHCR reported 1.7 million registered Afghan refugees in Pakistan, with the largest communities in Peshawar, quetta and Karachi. But the number of unregistered remains unknown.

Go to Page :   1 2 3  

 
 

Readers' Comments

Total Comments 3

Jonathan Ross
4 March 2011
11:28 PM
The means by which we live have outdistanced the ends for which we live. Our scientific power has outrun our spiritual power. We have micro wave radiation,wifi,taser's,poverty,depleted uranium.hungry children,wars, bombs,guided missiles and misguided men.
 

tahir
4 February 2011
02:38 PM
Very informative article regarding the plight of refugees and the people serving the humanity selflessly.
 

Tahir
4 February 2011
12:09 AM
Very good thought provoking article. Condition of poor is very bad in Pakistan. Those who help the needy and miserable are dear to God and will be rewarded by Him.
 
1
 
Name :    Place :    Email :   

 
 
Home | The Lede | Letters From | Perspectives | Reporting & Essays | Arts & Reviews | Fiction & Poetry | Books | Bookshelf | The Showcase | Subscribe | About Us
In this Issue | Cover Story | Archive | Photo Essay | Most Read | Register | Advertise With Us