Reportage

The Land Of Illusion

By VISHAL ARORA | 1 June 2010

ABOUT THREE-AND-A-HALF HOURS from Bangalore, past farmers’ fields and some hills, a small village came into view. The rural area gradually gave way to an airstrip, where a private jet was parked, and then to uptown buildings—resorts, hotels and a huge, pink building, the Sri Sathya Sai Institute of Higher Medical Sciences, Prasanthigram, a ‘super specialty hospital’ designed by English architect Dr Keith Critchlow, close to the Sri Sathya Sai Hill View Stadium, inaugurated in November 2006 by then President of India APJ Abdul Kalam, who also happens to be a well-regarded nuclear scientist.

This is Puttaparthi, a small town in the Anantapur district of Andhra Pradesh spread over approximately ten square kilometres. The names of almost all hotels and shops start with ‘Sai.’ Pictures of Sathya Sai Baba are everywhere—on all shop hoardings, on the backs of auto-rickshaws, in lifts and telephone booths and even inside the Puttaparthi police station and the post office. The pictures also carry prominent Sai Baba-isms: ‘Help Ever, Hurt Never,’ ‘Love is God, Live in Love,’ ‘Unity, Purity and Divinity,’ ‘Love All, Serve All,’ and so on. With his benevolent teachings, his emphasis on communal harmony, and his numerous social work projects, Sai Baba seems like Puttaparthi’s own deity.

Everything in the village appears in line with Sai Baba’s worldview. There are many massage parlours—Sai Baba himself claims to be a “masseur healer.” Given his aversion to alcohol and tobacco, cigarettes and liquor are sold only secretly. But you can find several paan shops—Sai Baba is a paan (betel leaf and nut) eater, as his stained teeth also suggest. Almost all restaurants are vegetarian, mirroring Sai Baba’s philosophy that “meat eating fosters animal qualities in man making him descend to the demoniac level.” Puttaparthi often seems like Sai Baba’s personal kingdom.

Coming here to meet and follow one of the world’s most influential living gurus—although it didn’t involve an undercover investigation—turned out to be one of my most taxing assignments. I was advised by many former devotees, and explicitly warned by his current disciples, not to write critically about the spiritual leader whose followers include the President of India, Pratibha Devisingh Patil, the founder of the Hard Rock Café and legions of the Indian social elite.

At Hotel Sai Renaissance, where I stayed, the staff dutifully advised me what wasn’t permitted at the ashram. “Please deposit your camera and phone, and also the pen I can see in your pocket,” said the middle-aged man in a stern voice, as if he was part of Sai Baba’s security team.

Just to make sure I got the message, the notice board at the entrance of Sai Baba’s ashram, the Sai Kulwant Hall, warned that phones, tape recorders and cameras were not allowed. Not even a pen. Thankfully, I was carrying none.

Sathya Sai Baba, which roughly translates as the ‘real Sai Baba,’ claims to have been born Sathyanarayan Raju on 23 November 1926, though proof of his actual birth date is hard to come by. In October 1940, he claimed that he was an incarnation of the Sai Baba of Shirdi, a guru from Maharashtra who lived until 1918 and was revered by Hindus and Muslims. These days, he claims to be the creator of the universe, Krishna, Christ, Jehovah and Allah, all in one.

I wanted to find out why and how Sai Baba’s millions of followers, mainly Hindus, Christians and Buddhists, believe in his divinity even decades after numerous former devotees went public with accusations of sexual abuse of boys and male adults, massive cover-ups and even murder. These allegations have made Sathya Sai Baba a regular on numerous cult watch websites like rickross.com and factnet.org, where former members tell surprisingly similar stories. In the face of such overwhelming evidence of malfeasance, how does faith among the denizens of Sai Baba’s Puttaparthi fiefdom remain so strong?

AT SAI BABA’S ASHRAM, I witnessed the susceptibility of faith from close quarters. Faith, they say, is seeing what is unseen, but here it apparently meant unseeing what is clearly seen.

At the Sai Kulwant Hall, over 10,000 people—men, women and children, locals and foreigners—were singing bhajans in Telugu, praising Hindu gods, mainly Shiva, Rama and Ganesha, and occasionally Sathya Sai Baba. Clad in a saffron robe, Sai Baba was sitting on a red padded wheelchair, referred to as his throne by his devotees. His signature afro framed his head. Two young men stood on either side of his ‘throne,’ which was placed between two four-foot tall golden lions on the slightly elevated stage. The roof above, painted in deep green with gold motifs and illuminated with crystal chandeliers, enhanced the grandeur of the daily darshan ceremony. Women were seated to his left, men to his right, on the black and white marble floor. Many in both wings prostrated themselves towards Sai Baba.

The frail-looking Sai Baba was quiet, with no expression on his wrinkled face. Occasionally, he patted his thigh to the beat of the bhajans. Carrying a white handkerchief in his left hand, he often wiped his mouth and nose, his right hand moving rarely, as if partially paralysed. His two volunteers would often kneel down to whisper in his ears or listen to him, as if receiving divine instructions. After a few bhajans, his volunteers rang a five-foot golden bell. It was time to offer the concluding hymn to Sai Baba, called the Mangal arati, a Telugu version of Om Jai Jagadish Hare, a Hindu devotional song from the 1870s.

As the arati ended, Sai Baba’s throne was wheeled towards his car, an imported silver Toyota Porte MPV parked adjacent to the stage. It bore the registration number AP 02 N 9000. The front door of the car slid open, making room for the wheelchair. As the volunteers escorted him to his car—to ferry him to his residence, barely 50 metres from the hall—an elderly man came to the stage to make an “important announcement.” “There will be a public meeting tomorrow evening to celebrate the anniversary of Bhagwan’s [God’s] mother [commemorated as Easwaramma Day].” He then proudly revealed that the President of India would also come to “seek Bhagwan’s blessings.” The devotees applauded but dispersed minutes after after Sai Baba’s departure—no one else matters in Puttaparthi but the 84-year-old Swami.

After darshan, I went to the Sai Towers Restaurant for supper. I was offered the only table with a vacant chair. A couple from Hong Kong, Allan and Linda Yeoh, Catholics by birth but Sai Baba’s devotees for 15 years, were in the middle of their meal. After pleasantries, the couple began to minister to me. “Swami came into our lives in 1995,” said the fair, well-dressed Allan. His wife Linda, a fashionable woman, showed me her necklace and said it was materialised by Sai Baba—with a wave of his hand, Sai Baba miraculously creates items such as watches, rings, necklaces and vibhuti (holy ash) and gifts them to his devotees.

Allan, a barrister, tells me he currently sits on the boards of several businesses in Hong Kong. Both he and Linda became devotees after reading a book on Sai Baba, The Embodiment of Love. Linda said she was “overwhelmed with love,” something that she had “always craved for.” “It was not something psychic, which is too limited a word to describe my feelings,” she said. “Baba is not just any other human being; he is Bhagwan.” Allan is among very few people who appear on stage with Sai Baba and have been asked to share their views during a darshan gathering.

Allan then told of his friend in Hong Kong, whom he identified as Phillip, also a Catholic. Telling stories of Sai Baba’s miracles to newer devotees is routine in Puttaparthi, and is encouraged by senior devotees for the expansion of Sai Baba’s ‘kingdom.’ So Phillip wanted to see God, continued Allan. When he was a child, his Catholic schoolteacher hit him on his knuckles until they bled as punishment for refusing to believe in God until he saw him. Years later, when he was in Puttaparthi for darshan, Sai Baba came to him, touched his knuckles and asked, “Does it still hurt?” When Phillip looked at Sai Baba, he asked him if he was happy to see God (Sai Baba). “Phillip cried, recalling the day at school when he was hit on his knuckles.”

Broaching Puttaparthi’s most taboo topic, I reminded Allan, “Sai Baba has been accused of sexually molesting children and faking miracles.” Though a little uncomfortable, Allan seemed sensible enough to at least attempt to answer my questions. He said he saw vibhuti coming from Sai Baba’s palm and “it was not an illusion. These allegations [of sexual abuse] are not a big deal.”

TANYA DATTA, who produced a BBC documentary on Sathya Sai Baba, encountered a similar climate:

On my first visit to Puttaparthi in 2003, I came across signs in the hostel warning guests that they could be arrested for ‘anti-Sai Baba activities.’ Although I had never heard of this law, the message seemed clear. During the making of the film, it became apparent that the Sai Baba lobby harnesses significant clout within powerful circles. These vested interests conspire to silence criticism and isolate those victims brave enough to tell their stories of abuse.

Allegations against Sai Baba aren’t new. “When I first started investigating him, I found allegations of a sexual nature dating back to the 70s,” Datta said. “The only constant was that these claims had not been investigated by the authorities.”

The testimony of one of Sai Baba’s ex-devotees seems pretty damning. In a signed statement dated 21 March 2001, furnished to me by a Delhi-based lawyer, Kamini Jaiswal, American Al Rahm alleged that Sai Baba had sexually molested him and his son. Rahm, then 45, and his wife Marisa, then 44, believed for 26 years that Sai Baba was a living God. During those years they frequented his ashram.

 In the spring of 1974, when Al Rahm was 18, he said he was called for a private interview with Sai Baba:

He seemed able to read my thoughts and appeared to manifest some oil with the wave of his hand. He said he was going to heal a digestive problem. As he rubbed the oil on my solar plexus, he lowered my pants and applied it to my genitals. Then he hugged me and began to kiss me on the mouth while pulling his legs up firmly against my genitals. He told me that he was my pleasure. Finally… he said that I should never tell anyone because they would not understand. I thought he was telling me that all pleasure and all experiences came through our relationship with God.  At the time I couldn’t believe that he would have any sexual desire towards me and that it must be a cosmic message. After all, he is Sai Baba, the one presidents, prime ministers, doctors and lawyers come to from around the world.

After leaving the interview, Rahm said he met a follower named Johnima, whose band Lightstorm often sang for Baba and who had received many interviews. He told him about the incident. “Welcome to the club,” he said Johnima told him. “He’s done it to all of us. Swami does that to reduce our sex drive and help us with our spiritual path.”

Johnima denies this conversation ever took place. “All His actions are prompted by complete love and Motherly care,” he wrote about Sai Baba in his first email. A day later he wrote a second email regarding Rahm, “We were acquaintances in the 70s and he most likely confused me with someone else. We find that misery or egos enjoy company.” 

 In June 1995, Sai Baba called Rahm’s 16-year-old son Alaya for two private interviews. “[Alaya] said that Baba had applied oil to his genitals and had kissed him on the mouth,” Rahm said. The alleged incident seemed strikingly similar to his own encounter with Sai Baba in 1974.

 In July 1997, during a conference when more than 18,000 young adults flocked to Puttaparthi, Baba called Alaya and his family for a combined 21 interviews. Rahm recalled:

Each of the family interviews ended with Baba seeing Alaya alone. In early interviews, Baba had placed Alaya’s hand on Baba’s genitals. There was a hump indicating that Baba had a penis. Then Baba blew on his finger as if to show magic and the hump disappeared. Baba said, ‘See, I am male and female. God is both man and woman.’

 Alaya would be invited for many more interviews until 1999, when he finally revealed the abuse to his parents. “In every one of his private interviews he was pressured by Sai Baba to engage in sexual activities with him,” Rahm alleged. “On one occasion Sai Baba threatened to cause an accident and have Alaya’s penis cut off if he ever shared it with anyone other than Sai Baba.”

Rahm also said that Sai Baba told his son, “That is my property only,” allegedly pointing to Alaya’s penis.

 After hearing the accusations, Rahm immediately phoned Dr William Harvey, a fellow officer in the organisation. Harvey called it a test of their faith. Rahm then met Michael Goldstein, Sai Baba’s international coordinator, who seemed torn by the news. He promised to investigate.

But then he returned from India. “Swami responded by saying ‘Swami is pure,’” Goldstein allegedly said.

“Goldstein lied and has lied for many years all the while keeping sexual allegations about Sai Baba from innocent families like ours who were later abused by Sai Baba,” Rahm continued. “It could have been avoided if he took his position responsibly and admitted to the people that there had been devotees come forward with complaints since as early as the 1970s.”

 Al Rahm also said he telephoned Berniece Mead, who headed Sai Baba’s young adult educational programme in the US. Rahm said Mead wasn’t surprised the allegations were sexual in nature: “It always is.” Then she quietly ended the call, saying, “I wish you the best.”

 “Sai Baba has said that the king makes the laws but the king is above the law,” Rahm continued. “Devotees are brainwashed. Many of them believe [Alaya’s] entire story and then say, ‘Well, Baba is god so he can do whatever he wants.’”

The Caravan attempted to contact Goldstein, Mead and Harvey. They did not respond.

 Alaya Rahm went public with his allegations in a 2004 BBC documentary. “Every step of the way has caused Internet disaster for my family,” Al Rahm explained. “At some point we just want to be finished with it.” Begged by other ex-devotees and their attorneys to sue the organisation, Alaya finally agreed even though his father had cautioned against it. His attorney attempted to sue the Sathya Sai Central Council of America. But when he discovered that they were only a book store with no tangible assets, his lawyer withdrew the case.

Rahm said that Alaya didn’t go public seeking a financial windfall:

 Alaya had met many other boys who were abused but were afraid and unwilling to talk about it. If he could have had some financial compensation for what he went through I am sure he would have taken it. He has suffered a lot and his family has supported him in every way to heal the scars not only of Sai Baba but also the Internet information that is available for everyone to see. It makes it difficult when applying for employment or trying to build a new professional reputation.

INDIAN-AMERICAN HARI SAMPATH, a former member of the ashram’s inner security wing, didn’t respond to repeated emails seeking comment. In an affidavit to the Central Bureau of Investigation dated 12 March 2001, however, he said the hostel officials of Sai Baba’s institutions “have known [about the alleged abuse] all along, and many of them even ‘feed’ young boys to Sai Baba.”

While the Rahms, Sampath, and a few others finally came forward, the majority of Sai Baba’s devotees remain faithful. While high-profile devotees may find it politically expedient to support Sai Baba, many rank and file members may fear that terrible things will happen if they question the leader, his doctrine or actions, said Steven Alan Hassan, who counsels people leaving cults. “They have also been told not to have negative thoughts, which short-circuit critical thinking and reality testing.”

Hassan, who has authored two books on cults, came up with the BITE Model to explain how cults control the minds of their followers:

If Behaviour, Information, Thoughts and Emotions (BITE) can be controlled, then an individual’s identity can be systematically manipulated and changed. Destructive mind control takes the locus of control away from an individual. The person is systematically deceived about the beliefs and practices of the person (or group) and manipulated throughout the recruitment process—unable to make informed choices and exert independent judgment. The person’s identity is profoundly influenced through a set of social influence techniques and a new identity is created—programmed to be dependent on the leader or group ideology. The person can’t think for him or herself, but believes otherwise.

The devotees in Puttaparthi are brainwashed, agrees Narendra Nayak, the national president of the Federation of Indian Rationalist Associations. “The reports of so-called healing may be in cases with a psychosomatic element. As for investigations into the so-called phenomena of materialisation, he has been asked many, many times to let us investigate that under foolproof conditions. But we have not been allowed to do so.”

Even without a controlled environment, Sai Baba’s miracles don’t stand up to real scrutiny. On 29 August 1992, Sai Baba inaugurated a community hall in Hyderabad in the presence of then Prime Minister PV Narasimha Rao and other dignitaries. Sai Baba materialised a chain for the building’s architect. One of the cameras placed by the government-owned Doordarshan news channel caught Sai Baba’s personal assistant passing over the chain to him. But the director of Hyderabad Doordarshan, Appa Rao, “personally directed that all copies of the tapes be destroyed.” (Deccan Chronicle, 23 November 1992) However, independent television producers who had also captured the day’s events widely circulated the recording in Hyderabad. Today, there are over a dozen videos on YouTube exposing Sai Baba’s fake miracles.

More serious allegations surfaced in June 1993 when four of Sai Baba’s young devotees reportedly tried to kill him. At 10:30 pm, as Sai Baba prepared for bed, the four, carrying daggers hidden in cloth, sought to enter his bedroom (The Times of India, 7 June 1993). Four other devotees serving as bodyguards tried to obstruct them, and the intruders stabbed two bodyguards to death. Sai Baba pressed an alarm button, alerting Puttaparthi police. Over 1,000 devotees living in the ashram crowded the main building. Heavily armed police arrived and, ‘in self defence’ killed the four intruders who only had daggers.

The encounter raised serious questions. Most notably, why did the four slain devotees plan to kill Sai Baba? And what exactly were their grievances? No one is sure and answers will likely prove hard to find. “The matter is purely internal and we do not wish to have any law enforcement agency investigating into it,” said Indulal Shah, chief functionary of the Sri Sathya Sai World Trust, to The Hindu.  

In December 1993, the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) registered a case against the Puttaparthi police for shooting the four men to death. In a statement to the local court on 30 December, the CID pointed out that the police had tampered with the crime scene, shifting the dead bodies to support the official police version of events. As detailed in the BBC documentary, the case was eventually dropped through the intervention of the Central government.

WITH THESE INCIDENTS IN MIND, I felt overwhelmed on my first night in Puttaparthi. It didn’t help that copies of the graphic affidavits were lying next to my pillow in my hotel room, which also happened to feature several pictures of Sai Baba. I fell asleep early.

On Easwaramma Day, my second morning in town, I left my phone, pen and camera in the room and started for the ashram where hundreds of devotees had lined up before the gate at 5:00 am so they could sit closer to Sai Baba. I removed my sandals and kept them on one of the racks placed outside the Sai Kulwant Hall. The ashram was crowded by 7:00. By 8:00, there were around 10,000 people, all seated with their hands folded in reverence. At 8:30, there was sudden commotion in the women’s wing. Sai Baba was to distribute saris to women and lemon rice and sweet pongal to all devotees, I was told. Women from Puttaparthi were desperate to enter the hall, pushing and pulling each other to be able to sit closer to the stage. Their shouts and shrieks sounded like rain falling on a tin rooftop and spoke volumes about the poverty of the local people.

By 9:00, the crowd had swelled to around 15,000. Finally, Sai Baba’s Toyota appeared. Swami wore a turmeric yellow robe, and was seated next to a clean-shaven, fair-skinned young man wearing spectacles with gold-coloured frames. Two police officials on duty were standing near the car, folding their hands—they looked more like devotees than police on duty. The car slowly came to the hall and the crowd began to fold their hands over their heads—Sai Baba was looking out of the rolled-down window, but he wore the expressionless gaze of a man ravaged by old age. Moving through the hall, his car went out to the grave of his mother (Hindus also bury their dead in Puttaparthi). Outside the ashram, people gathered to get a glimpse of Sai Baba.

At 9:45 am, Sai Baba’s car returned to the Sai Kulwant Hall. Local musicians began playing shehnai and mridang, their backs towards the crowd and facing the stage. A dark, stout young man came and sat next to me.

“Do you like Swami?” he asked. Not wanting to give a clear-cut answer, I replied, “I am a newcomer.” He introduced himself as Shiva. “My actual name is Adi, but people call me Shiva. I drive an auto-rickshaw.”

He was from the same village as Sai Baba. “I had no job, but Swami’s brother wrote a letter to the ashram, requesting them to give me a job,” he said. “All I have is because of Swami. He gives rice and dal to all the poor people of the village once a week.”

Shiva later became my guide. Pointing to a man wearing white trousers and shirt and holding a cellphone, Shiva said the man had been a deputy inspector of police in Hyderabad, but he quit his job to serve Sai Baba. Then he pointed towards a longhaired foreigner, wearing white pyjama and kurta, with a trimmed black beard and moustache, talking to Allan Yeoh on the stage. “He is Isaac Tigrett, a big businessman who donated money for the Sathya Sai hospital that offers free treatment, including surgery, to all villagers.”

Tigrett founded the Hard Rock Café and House of Blues. These days, however, the 62-year-old Tigrett lives in Sai Baba’s ashram. He travels and gives discourses on the teachings, and is building a spiritual retreat centre, The Mystic Inn of the 7th Ray, “at the behest of his Master,” as his personal website says. I had questions for Tigrett, who’d told the BBC that his faith wouldn’t be shattered even if the accusations against Sai Baba proved true. Tigrett, like Yeoh, occupied the inner wing of the Sai Kulwant Hall, close to the stage with Sai Baba, where only devotees with special identity cards and wearing white clothes were allowed. I waited for him after the darshan gatherings, but he disappeared each time, perhaps using a special exit. Allan Yeoh suggested that I could talk to him if I came across him in the street. But that never happened.

Having eaten lemon rice and sweet pongal for breakfast, I left the hall and looked for my sandals on the rack. They weren’t there, most likely stolen. I walked to my hotel, around 500 metres from there, barefoot, hoping that people wouldn’t take it as a mark of devotion for Sai Baba.

I explained to the man at the front desk why I was barefoot. “It’s good, Mr Arora,” he said. “Losing sandals is considered auspicious, signifying that Satan has fled your life.”

“Never mind,” I said, and went to my room.

The devotees flocked the Sai Kulwant Hall again at 4:00 pm for the evening function. Sai Baba came at around 5:00 pm, this time without the car, with two devotees pushing his wheelchair. With Sai Baba close enough to touch, there was remarkable excitement in the crowd. A middle-aged man, standing next to me, a teacher of history in a local university, threw his bag down to promptly fold his hands in worship of Sai Baba. “We are very lucky today; this is an unusual darshan,” said the man, a devotee for 20 years. Sai Baba went close to the women devotees, who tried to touch his ‘lotus feet,’ a Buddhist symbol of devotion. He came to the men’s wing, cutting across the crowd, getting closer to the devotees. They too touched his feet and folded their hands.

Sai Baba took his place on the stage and the chanting of Om began, followed by bhajans. Sai Baba was quiet, as usual. Undergraduate students from the Sri Sathya Sai University enacted a play depicting the lives of Sai Baba’s parents. After the play ended, at around 6:30 pm, a microphone was taken to Sai Baba, and people applauded, hoping to hear the voice of their Swami. I was not surprised that Sai Baba did not speak a word. A video of Sai Baba’s 83rd birthday celebration clearly showed his struggle with the symptoms of old age: he was barely able to speak and forgot the name of one of his closest associates. Most of the people in the video laughed, but seemingly very few saw the god losing his memory as a reason to question his divinity.

Instead, the microphone was removed and given to a professor from the university, who, standing behind a podium, announced again that the President of India would be coming to seek ‘Bhagwan’s’ blessings the following day.

There is no lack of powerful, high-profile people cutting across political parties and spheres, professing their faith in Sai Baba. Justice PN Bhagwati, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of India in 1985 and 1986, calls him “divinity incarnate” in Baba is God in Human Form: Experiences of Divinity of Bhagwan Sri Sathya Sai Baba. In the same book, Shivraj Vishwanath Patil, currently Governor of Punjab and former Union Home Minister, says, “He is the knowledge; He is the wisdom personified.” Shankarrao Bhavrao Chavan, former Chief Minister of Maharashtra for two terms and former Union Home and Finance Minister, says he has “no hesitation in saying, whatever position and status I have is purely because of Bhagwan’s blessings.”

IN THE EVENING, I was again at the Sai Towers Restaurant. The Yeohs were having their dinner—rice and curry. Sitting at the same table, I ordered uttapam, and our conversation began. “So we were talking about the allegations against Sai Baba?” I said. Allan and Linda seemed more frank that evening. At first, Allan admitted that it took Linda a few days to restore her faith after the BBC telecast the documentary on the allegations in June 2004. “But,” he carried on, “it [sex] is all about union; maybe Sai Baba established union with some of his devotees. I am not saying that the allegations were necessarily true, but what is the big deal even if they were true?” he asked. “So that won’t affect your faith in him?” I asked. “No, it will not,” he replied. “But is it fair that he tries to establish ‘union’ with some of their devotees without their consent?” I asked. “If he is God, how can it be wrong? It’s Ok,” he replied, rendering me speechless.

What about his fake miracles? “I think sometimes Sai Baba does fake miracles,” Allan admitted. “That’s because God has a great sense of humour.” “Humour?” I asked. “Yes, he does it to further offend those who do not believe in him because their karmas are bad. He is God, and he doesn’t need to prove anything. It’s a fact that will remain whether someone believes in him or not.”

Acceptance of Sai Baba’s alleged criminal activities by his devotees is their personal choice. But, surely, a government cannot overlook such serious accusations. Several foreign agencies, including the US Department of State, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the German Office of Prosecutions, the French Sûreté (Security) and the British Home Office, officially acknowledged receiving complaints against Sai Baba, but they could do little as the alleged crimes were committed in India.

Legally, in India at least, charges against Sai Baba seem to have no traction. The petition of Indian-American ex-follower Hari Sampath was dismissed by Indian Supreme Court Justices GB Pattnaik and RC Lahoti on 8 May 2001.

In her May 2008 petition to the Supreme Court, Kamini Jaiswal, Sampath’s lawyer, wrote that they were “sure not to get justice at the hands of the [Andhra Pradesh] state machinery” as Sai Baba had “practically mesmerised the system.” They sought the court’s direction to the CBI to conduct a free, fair and impartial inquiry. The CBI did not respond to the complaint filed by Hari Sampath and others, which is why Sampath approached the Supreme Court. “Hari Sampath disappeared after that,” Jaiswal said. “He didn’t respond to emails, and he did not even pay the lawyers’ fees.” Sampath wouldn’t speak on the record. He did, however, send The Caravan the CBI report.

When I met Jaiswal in South Delhi in the summer of 2009, she still seemed close to the case. “I have no respect for a human being who claims to be God,”  she said. “Sai Baba has mesmerised people; it’s all bogus.”

IN THE LAST DECADE OR SO, the battle between Sai Baba’s supporters and detractors has moved online, where it only seems to have intensified. Robert Priddy, a sociologist and former national leader of the Sathya Sai Centre in Oslo, Norway, says Sai Baba’s admirers threaten him. After Priddy’s blog carried allegations of Sai Baba’s misdeeds, a man identifying himself as Mohan left this comment on 26 November 2008: “Sai Baba is god and his devotees love to see him on the golden chariot…If you come in front of me I will kill you man.”

Much of the hate, Priddy alleges, is orchestrated by Sai Baba admirer Gerald Joe Moreno of New Mexico. “Many ex-followers from outside India [are not] in a position to take action against Sathya Sai Baba. They have not been silenced, though some may wish not to be stalked by Gerald Moreno, who is fanatically and obsessively aggressive on the Internet.”

When The Caravan contacted Gerald Moreno, he said, “Ex-devotees are dishonest and aggressive individuals who resort to public humiliation, character assassination, defamations and libels against anyone who has the courage to speak out against their hate-based agendas.” Moreno, who on his website says he is “an open-minded agnostic” but believes that Sai Baba “possesses genuine paranormal powers,” also said he was “not a Sai devotee.” He added that he had written a few articles about the “bogus” claims of ex-devotees and was “drawn increasingly” into the “debate” on Sai Baba after ex-devotees began their “smear campaigns against me.”

Shortly after his first email, Moreno sent a follow-up. He’d found that my domain, www.vishalarora.co.in, was registered to an address at the New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary, where my brother studied. 

Apparently, my Christianity “raised red flags.” He expressed concern that The Caravan would be biased.

“Therefore, I kindly ask that you maintain transparency in your writings pertaining to Sathya Sai Baba so that you will not be accused of bias or having ulterior motives like Vir Sanghvi, Paul Lewis and Tanya Datta,” he continued.

He also—not so subtly—threatened me: “If your article does not give due justice to both sides of the Sai Controversy, I will be forced to write about this issue and make it public.”

A few days later, he made good on his threat: “Apparently, you have made your decision and therefore I am making mine. I am releasing the following webpages about you:

“-Vishal Arora - New Delhi Journalist - Arora, Vishal / -Email Correspondence with Vishal Arora.” Even before this issue went to press, these pages on Moreno’s site appear in the top five Google hits for ‘Vishal Arora.’

MY THIRD DAY IN PUTTAPARTHI started early. People began lining up at the ashram at 5:00 am. The Sai Kulwant Hall, however, filled up only at around 7:30. By 8:45, the chanting began, chandeliers were lit and bhajans were sung. Sai Baba’s car could be seen on the left side of the stage, where everyone’s eyes were fixed, waiting for yet another darshan. However, at 9:30, the arati began, indicating that darshan would be granted only in the evening when the President arrived.

At 11:30, I went to the Public Relations Office beside the Sai Kulwant Hall. A middle-aged man wearing white trousers and shirt and a red vermilion streak on his forehead was sitting behind an office table. I introduced myself as a journalist.

“Can I meet an official of the Sri Sathya Sai Central Trust?” I asked politely. “Everything is mentioned in a booklet available for sale for 15 rupees. Buy that and you will know everything about the ashram,” the public relations officer (PRO) suggested. “Can I meet Swami?” I asked. I expected his reply: “No, it’s not possible.”

But I didn’t expect what followed: “But why don’t you pray? He will appear in your vision and you can talk to him. And no matter where you are sitting when Sai Baba is giving darshan, if you pray enough, you may even be called for a private interview. This has happened hundreds of times here.”

(Getting an interview where one could raise sensitive topics, however, seemed a tad more challenging. Sathya Sai Baba was last interviewed by journalists from the Mumbai edition of The Times of India 12 March 1999, the only interview after one in Blitz News Magazine in September 1976. Both interviews seemed meant for devotees and didn’t broach allegations or controversies.)

The PRO started packing up, saying, “My time is up. I am here from 10:30 to 11:30 am every morning, and I’ll need to go now.”

“I am sorry, I didn’t ask your name,” I said. “You don’t need to know my name,” he replied. “I am the public relations officer here, and an engineer by profession. “Can I meet you again?” I asked gently. “If I am in my office,” he said, and left the room.

I REACHED THE ANONYMOUS PRO’S OFFICE at 11:00 am the following day.

“Why didn’t your department respond to the allegations?” I asked. “When dogs bark at an elephant, do you think the elephant runs after them?” he said. He began narrating yet another story on Sai Baba’s divinity:

There was a guru, known as Elephant Baba, in Mumbai, who had spent 12 years learning to walk on water. He challenged Babaji to walk on the sea. Babaji went to Mumbai and asked him to walk first. As he put his first foot on water, he went into it. He could not walk and developed many diseases. Later he came to the ashram asking for forgiveness, and then he was healed.

Babaji walked on water when he was seven. He was going to school and the river in Puttaparthi was flooded. But he walked. Many people saw him. He was born with siddhi (perfection); unlike others, he doesn’t need to acquire it.

 “How does Babaji spend his day? Does he meditate?” I asked. The PRO replied, “Who will he meditate to? He is God. He normally travels around the world to help his devotees while his body remains in his room.” I didn’t know how to respond. I chose to keep quiet. Then the PRO said something significant. “He has warned his attendants not to even try to see what he does in his room.” Maybe he practises magic tricks, I wondered.

Sai Baba has made numerous such claims, comparing himself to Jesus Christ—most notably, being born through an immaculate conception. In His Story, he says, “I am the Director of the Cosmic Play. The entire universe dances to My tune... I can do anything. Everything is in My hands.” He also calls himself “king of kings.” He even claims to have resurrected dead people.

His followers also ascribe similar divine powers to their guru. Take, for example, when I asked Sai Baba’s PRO, “How many languages can Babaji speak?”

“He is omniscient. He speaks all the languages you have in the world. He went to Africa a few years ago, and he spoke to a very old lady in Swahili,” he responded, while looking at his watch. I got the message.

ONE DOESN’T NEED TO SPEND much time in Puttaparthi to see the streets thronged. Seeing the mystical powers that the PRO described, however, presented more of a challenge. I’d hoped to witness something supernatural when Sai Baba received President Pratibha Devisingh Patil at the ashram. Patil arrived in her Ambassador with her daughter Jyoti Rathod, son-in-law Jayesh Rathod, and her granddaughter Vedika Rathod. Accompanying Patil’s family was Andhra Pradesh Tourism Minister J Geetha Reddy, a regular visitor to the ashram.

After a special tea party for the honoured guests, a media scrum ensued. Security at the ashram’s main entrance began frisking visitors more strictly. I took a few pictures, fearing that I would soon be barred from using my camera. Sure enough, a volunteer security man came over and asked for my identity card. I showed my press card. “I don’t know how you have been allowed to enter with your camera,” he said, and left. Then another volunteer came running towards me and asked for my camera. I moved away slightly to pacify him and said, “I am sorry, but some other press people are also taking pictures.” He insisted that I give my camera to him. I moved further away from him. He asked a policeman standing next to me to snatch the camera from me. He did, and gave it to the volunteer.

Holding my camera in his hand, he asked me to come to the hall’s entrance. He gave the camera to another volunteer asking him to “delete all the pictures.” I rushed to the entrance and asked for my camera. “No, I’ve been asked to delete the pictures,” he insisted. He switched on the camera and tried to locate the delete function but could not. As a crowd started gathering around me, another security man came and asked his colleague to return the camera so the crowd would disperse. He did, and I merged with the throng.

By then, the President was about to leave. Wearing a golden sari with broad maroon borders draped over her head, President Patil briefly appeared on the stage with her two official escorts, who slowly walked with her towards the car. She waved at the devotees as she slid into the Ambassador. Then Sai Baba entered the stage amid the chanting. The devotees seemed less enthusiastic, perhaps because they wanted to see Sai Baba and Pratibha Devisingh Patil together. After the arati, Sai Baba left the stage, again without speaking a word or performing a miracle.

The whole encounter recalled an earlier conversation with the media guy. He’d advised me to read Sai Baba’s Sandeha Nivarini: Clearance of Spiritual Doubts.

Sai Baba’s teachings on doubt are unequivocal. “Do not admit doubt in you...The venom of doubt...Doubt is death...A component of the Raakshasa (demonic) nature.” And as Allan Yeoh told me, “Baba says, ‘It’s heart to heart, one to one.’ You don’t have to listen to others.” His wife Linda also explained how she overcame her doubts after watching the BBC documentary: “I just said I would look at my personal experience, and not what others are alleging.” For Sai Baba, this means losing only the ones who have personal grievances with him. The rest of his flock remains intact.

AND I WAS TO FIND A SIMILAR, dangerous, resilience of faith and disregard for doubt when I met devotee Dr Naresh K Bhatia, who in October 2000 had told the Daily Telegraph journalist Mick Brown over the phone that he had sexual relations with Sai Baba for a total of “15 or 16 years.” He was also aware that Sai Baba had relations with “many, many students from the college and school, and with devotees from overseas.” Also, The Findings, a dossier of testimonies of ex-devotees of Sai Baba on the Web, claims that Dr Bhatia exposed “massive sexual exploitation by Sathya Sai Baba of students, including a report on the physically injurious anal rape of a minor, a boy student, with which he personally confronted Sathya Sai Baba.” This led to “his immediate sacking from his position as head of the Blood Bank at Sathya Sai Baba’s hospital in Puttaparthi and total banishment from the ashrams and all Sai Baba institutions.” 

I read his account in the Daily Telegraph and several Internet forums; I wanted to meet the now 59-year-old Dr Bhatia. I went to see him in his house in Noida. The tall, fair man received me very gently and offered me a seat on a veranda next to his living room. There was a six-foot tall poster of Sai Baba on one of the walls. I wondered why he still had a picture of him.

I told him I wanted to know about his relationship with Sai Baba and whether or not the reports on the Internet were true. “What did you find in Puttaparthi?” he asked. I told him many of his former devotees wouldn’t make accusations against Sai Baba. I also complained that there seemed to be no real consequences for Sai Baba. “No action will be taken against him. Nothing will happen to him,” remarked Dr Bhatia. “I will suggest that you do not write the article.” I thought it was his pessimism.

“But why do you think nothing will happen to him?” I asked. “He is God,” he replied. “Is what I have read on the Internet about you untrue?” I asked. “Everything is true,” he said, “but so what?” The bell rang and he went to the door and came back with his colleague. I thought it would be difficult to have a frank conversation now. But Dr Bhatia carried on.

“What is evil, and what is good? Can you separate evil from good? They are two sides of the same coin,” he continued, looking at his friend for his approval, and he nodded. “It is the giving of one’s heart that is more important than giving one’s body. Jesus said if you look at a woman with lust, you have already committed adultery. This means your thoughts are more important than the acts done in body. So if you can give your heart to Sai Baba, what can you withhold? He is the creator.” For about an hour, he carried on with his confusing, contradictory, pantheistic argument.

Before I left he hugged me, kissed me on the cheek, said I was like a son to him and offered help in life. He also gave me a book he’d written, The Dreams and Realities: Face to face with God. The book details Bhatia’s own realisation of Sai Baba’s divinity. It was signed by Sai Baba, “With Love and Blessings, Sri Sathya Sai,” and dated 5 June 1993.

As he went to see me off at the gate, I asked him once again, this time categorically, if he had sexual relations with Sai Baba and if he had seen a child molested by him. “No, a hundred times no,” he said—a complete U-turn from his earlier admission. “I said the same to BBC journalists when they came to interview me in 2004, but they didn’t show any clip from that interview,” he added. I left, confused, wondering when and how he’d succumbed once again to the idea that a man accused of being a serial sex abuser could be God.  

Vishal Arora is a Delhi-based journalist who writes on religion, culture, politics and foreign affairs for media in India, the UK and the US.

ABOUT THREE-AND-A-HALF HOURS from Bangalore, past farmers’ fields and some hills, a small village came into view. The rural area gradually gave way to an airstrip, where a private jet was parked, and then to uptown buildings—resorts, hotels and a huge, pink building, the Sri Sathya Sai Institute of Higher Medical Sciences, Prasanthigram, a ‘super specialty hospital’ designed by English architect Dr Keith Critchlow, close to the Sri Sathya Sai Hill View Stadium, inaugurated in November 2006 by then President of India APJ Abdul Kalam, who also happens to be a well-regarded nuclear scientist.

This is Puttaparthi, a small town in the Anantapur district of Andhra Pradesh spread over approximately ten square kilometres. The names of almost all hotels and shops start with ‘Sai.’ Pictures of Sathya Sai Baba are everywhere—on all shop hoardings, on the backs of auto-rickshaws, in lifts and telephone booths and even inside the Puttaparthi police station and the post office. The pictures also carry prominent Sai Baba-isms: ‘Help Ever, Hurt Never,’ ‘Love is God, Live in Love,’ ‘Unity, Purity and Divinity,’ ‘Love All, Serve All,’ and so on. With his benevolent teachings, his emphasis on communal harmony, and his numerous social work projects, Sai Baba seems like Puttaparthi’s own deity.

Everything in the village appears in line with Sai Baba’s worldview. There are many massage parlours—Sai Baba himself claims to be a “masseur healer.” Given his aversion to alcohol and tobacco, cigarettes and liquor are sold only secretly. But you can find several paan shops—Sai Baba is a paan (betel leaf and nut) eater, as his stained teeth also suggest. Almost all restaurants are vegetarian, mirroring Sai Baba’s philosophy that “meat eating fosters animal qualities in man making him descend to the demoniac level.” Puttaparthi often seems like Sai Baba’s personal kingdom.

Coming here to meet and follow one of the world’s most influential living gurus—although it didn’t involve an undercover investigation—turned out to be one of my most taxing assignments. I was advised by many former devotees, and explicitly warned by his current disciples, not to write critically about the spiritual leader whose followers include the President of India, Pratibha Devisingh Patil, the founder of the Hard Rock Café and legions of the Indian social elite.

At Hotel Sai Renaissance, where I stayed, the staff dutifully advised me what wasn’t permitted at the ashram. “Please deposit your camera and phone, and also the pen I can see in your pocket,” said the middle-aged man in a stern voice, as if he was part of Sai Baba’s security team.

Just to make sure I got the message, the notice board at the entrance of Sai Baba’s ashram, the Sai Kulwant Hall, warned that phones, tape recorders and cameras were not allowed. Not even a pen. Thankfully, I was carrying none.

Sathya Sai Baba, which roughly translates as the ‘real Sai Baba,’ claims to have been born Sathyanarayan Raju on 23 November 1926, though proof of his actual birth date is hard to come by. In October 1940, he claimed that he was an incarnation of the Sai Baba of Shirdi, a guru from Maharashtra who lived until 1918 and was revered by Hindus and Muslims. These days, he claims to be the creator of the universe, Krishna, Christ, Jehovah and Allah, all in one.

I wanted to find out why and how Sai Baba’s millions of followers, mainly Hindus, Christians and Buddhists, believe in his divinity even decades after numerous former devotees went public with accusations of sexual abuse of boys and male adults, massive cover-ups and even murder. These allegations have made Sathya Sai Baba a regular on numerous cult watch websites like rickross.com and factnet.org, where former members tell surprisingly similar stories. In the face of such overwhelming evidence of malfeasance, how does faith among the denizens of Sai Baba’s Puttaparthi fiefdom remain so strong?

AT SAI BABA’S ASHRAM, I witnessed the susceptibility of faith from close quarters. Faith, they say, is seeing what is unseen, but here it apparently meant unseeing what is clearly seen.

At the Sai Kulwant Hall, over 10,000 people—men, women and children, locals and foreigners—were singing bhajans in Telugu, praising Hindu gods, mainly Shiva, Rama and Ganesha, and occasionally Sathya Sai Baba. Clad in a saffron robe, Sai Baba was sitting on a red padded wheelchair, referred to as his throne by his devotees. His signature afro framed his head. Two young men stood on either side of his ‘throne,’ which was placed between two four-foot tall golden lions on the slightly elevated stage. The roof above, painted in deep green with gold motifs and illuminated with crystal chandeliers, enhanced the grandeur of the daily darshan ceremony. Women were seated to his left, men to his right, on the black and white marble floor. Many in both wings prostrated themselves towards Sai Baba.

The frail-looking Sai Baba was quiet, with no expression on his wrinkled face. Occasionally, he patted his thigh to the beat of the bhajans. Carrying a white handkerchief in his left hand, he often wiped his mouth and nose, his right hand moving rarely, as if partially paralysed. His two volunteers would often kneel down to whisper in his ears or listen to him, as if receiving divine instructions. After a few bhajans, his volunteers rang a five-foot golden bell. It was time to offer the concluding hymn to Sai Baba, called the Mangal arati, a Telugu version of Om Jai Jagadish Hare, a Hindu devotional song from the 1870s.

As the arati ended, Sai Baba’s throne was wheeled towards his car, an imported silver Toyota Porte MPV parked adjacent to the stage. It bore the registration number AP 02 N 9000. The front door of the car slid open, making room for the wheelchair. As the volunteers escorted him to his car—to ferry him to his residence, barely 50 metres from the hall—an elderly man came to the stage to make an “important announcement.” “There will be a public meeting tomorrow evening to celebrate the anniversary of Bhagwan’s [God’s] mother [commemorated as Easwaramma Day].” He then proudly revealed that the President of India would also come to “seek Bhagwan’s blessings.” The devotees applauded but dispersed minutes after after Sai Baba’s departure—no one else matters in Puttaparthi but the 84-year-old Swami.

After darshan, I went to the Sai Towers Restaurant for supper. I was offered the only table with a vacant chair. A couple from Hong Kong, Allan and Linda Yeoh, Catholics by birth but Sai Baba’s devotees for 15 years, were in the middle of their meal. After pleasantries, the couple began to minister to me. “Swami came into our lives in 1995,” said the fair, well-dressed Allan. His wife Linda, a fashionable woman, showed me her necklace and said it was materialised by Sai Baba—with a wave of his hand, Sai Baba miraculously creates items such as watches, rings, necklaces and vibhuti (holy ash) and gifts them to his devotees.

Allan, a barrister, tells me he currently sits on the boards of several businesses in Hong Kong. Both he and Linda became devotees after reading a book on Sai Baba, The Embodiment of Love. Linda said she was “overwhelmed with love,” something that she had “always craved for.” “It was not something psychic, which is too limited a word to describe my feelings,” she said. “Baba is not just any other human being; he is Bhagwan.” Allan is among very few people who appear on stage with Sai Baba and have been asked to share their views during a darshan gathering.

Allan then told of his friend in Hong Kong, whom he identified as Phillip, also a Catholic. Telling stories of Sai Baba’s miracles to newer devotees is routine in Puttaparthi, and is encouraged by senior devotees for the expansion of Sai Baba’s ‘kingdom.’ So Phillip wanted to see God, continued Allan. When he was a child, his Catholic schoolteacher hit him on his knuckles until they bled as punishment for refusing to believe in God until he saw him. Years later, when he was in Puttaparthi for darshan, Sai Baba came to him, touched his knuckles and asked, “Does it still hurt?” When Phillip looked at Sai Baba, he asked him if he was happy to see God (Sai Baba). “Phillip cried, recalling the day at school when he was hit on his knuckles.”

Broaching Puttaparthi’s most taboo topic, I reminded Allan, “Sai Baba has been accused of sexually molesting children and faking miracles.” Though a little uncomfortable, Allan seemed sensible enough to at least attempt to answer my questions. He said he saw vibhuti coming from Sai Baba’s palm and “it was not an illusion. These allegations [of sexual abuse] are not a big deal.”

TANYA DATTA, who produced a BBC documentary on Sathya Sai Baba, encountered a similar climate:

On my first visit to Puttaparthi in 2003, I came across signs in the hostel warning guests that they could be arrested for ‘anti-Sai Baba activities.’ Although I had never heard of this law, the message seemed clear. During the making of the film, it became apparent that the Sai Baba lobby harnesses significant clout within powerful circles. These vested interests conspire to silence criticism and isolate those victims brave enough to tell their stories of abuse.

READER'S COMMENTS [87]

Loved this sentence - Faith, they say, is seeing what is unseen, but here it apparently meant unseeing what is clearly seen. - You had to go to Puttapurthi to catch a glimpse of this. But thanks to you, all we have to do now is to read some of the comments in this article. RIP Narendra Dabholkar.

hi Vishal, good article! it looks as if u never lost sandals in ur life! a true journalist really tries to do a good job. its not about his opinion about anything. its his oath to his profession to be true to it. A good article not only needs good preparation and language but also good research and First hand evidence. Just because Saibaba is dead and it is a hot topic, u dont have to write an article on him to get website hits and may be money through it. If u can see the hollow inside urself which made u write articles like this, thinking THIS is journalism, that is where Saibaba fits in. He tried to teach us to be true to ourselves. Write better so that people benefit from your articles not wasting your time and ours.

I am saddened that you would need a baba, Sathya Sai Baba or anybody, to help you realise that you need to be true to yourself. If you indeed must be true to yourself, as you claim your baba taught you to be, he would have told you to acknowledge your doubts and explore for answers. If he didn't, I don't know if you are kidding yourself or are letting the dead man kid you, even after he showed he is no immortal, lesser still, God, by DYING. Ramya, get help. If you wasted your time reading this article, you have no one to blame but yourself for coming here and reading this. Arora or Caravan or any one with any allegiance (or otherwise) to the two didn't ask you to come and read this and then cry for someone who, i reiterate, was just a man.

All those who were abused by this Baba yet suffer from Stockholm Syndrome should stand in a row like schoolboys in assembly, fold their hands and sing: 'Aap ke nazron ne samjha pyaar ki kabil mujhe-e-e-e-e'.

Please read "Avatar Of Night" by Tal Brooke.

Having lived more than a decade in Parthi, i am a lonely, confused and scared person, thinking to take my life because i have no hope for the future. Don't know where to go and how to get out of here. People ignore our agony and sadness and only platitudes are mouthed: "Don't worry, Baba will take care..." "Pray to Swami..." i am a human being and would need human compassion. Not to be found in Parthi. Talks, explanations, are all jumbled up with spiritual quotations and it suffocates me. Dr. Bhatia was accused as a sexist himself, today only i came to know that he spoke up against Swami and ashram. But the peope herer chose to blame him doing it in the hospital. i am scared and we were warned not to speak up, otherwise we would end up like David Baley of England. means in the police custotay.

The article in nice. Most comments are funny. Come on guys. Magic tricks and beauty parlours! Ridiculous for anyone to claim to be god incarnate. Neither did Jesus, Buddha or anyone else say so. They all said that there is a god. Enjoy your plight. Clearly, ignorance is bliss. True to core in this case.

I am Wondering that Indian Peoples are the Worst Foolish Peoples In the World. They Belive anything in the Name Of God. Thus Advantages For Bastards Like Puttapathi Sai, Nithyananda etc.... My Foolish Indian Friends We Are Educated, We Should Not Belive These F***ing S**ts. See I Belive God There Was A Power Controls Beyond Human Beings. Just Remember My Friends Please, Once Who See God Or He/She Got the Blessing From the God Will Don't Likes Whatever Human Loves Eg: Sex, Money, luxury life Etc..... But Here Its Opposite. Do u Peoples Know The Bank balance and Properties Of Mr.Puttapathi Sai? Sitting in a Golden Throne And Cheating Peoples. Shall I tell Who Got the True Blessing Of the God, Who Saw the God Ramanar, Shridi Sai Baba, Vallalar Those Peoples Are Real Mahan's. They Lived A Very Normal life, Tok Normal Food Not Lived In the Shadow of Royal And Rich. Kindly My Friends Please Dont Pray Humans, Please Pray God In Temples, Church And Mosque. Puttapathi is not a god he is magician black magician, Even David Blane And Chris Angels Can Do More than Puutapathi and nithyanandha Do'S ''BELIVE GOD BUT DONT BELIVE THE HUMAN BEING WHO SAYS I AM A GOD"

I wonder howmany people speaking out against Sathya Sai Baba have even visited His ashram and seen Him even once! How foolish it is to sit on the sidelines and criticize. First experience, then share your experience.

Dear friends, thanks for the news and all, let not forget that AS A HUMAN BEING HOW MUCH OF OUR TIME, WORTH and MONEY we are spending for the sake of our fellow human being. let first think about him as a great human being who served the mankind and promoted humanity. scandals and doubts - are normal for every one he is also not exception. but LET US TAKE GOOD and GROW GOOD and GO GOOD in our life. stop blaming.

Great article Vishal... The sad part is people are so mesmerised to sort the differenced between Good and Evil .
I remember an incident during my school days, the girl in my next class(Grade 8) was affected with cancer and her entire family believed blindly that the so called God Man will cure her sickness and waited in Puttaparthi for almost a week for his Darshan. He did not give his most value darshan, the girl’s condition worsened and in a week she died.
Unable to suffer this loss, the entire family including her aunt and Uncle ‘s family (I do not have the exact count) committed suicide.they killed the little Kids in the family too. I still do not understand why the entire family died even if the Girl was inseparable part of the family.The only one who survived was the girl’s uncle.
Whenever I here news about this person called Sai baba – It still leaves me hard feelings that he killed an entire family just cheating everyone that he could cure Cancer. I do not know how many people have died like this expecting a healing from a person who cannot heal.
And I think the Sai Trust would be devising wicked plans to bring up the movie - the Next incarnation and fool people again..

@ nobeatingroundthebush and @ MEHER BABA : Do u both have some Human thing atleast inside you. Just because somebody has an institute and does some good with the funds flooding does not mean he can commit serious crimes and still be free outside. If it had been any other person , you guys woould not have forgiven . Just because you ppl are so stupid to realize the truth , you can accep him with all the unpardonable acts of his. Not necessary that e very one should accept a Man with offensive acts and Cheap tricks to be God.

@ JAY NAIDU: You asked for other Charges against your so called God man and I have illustrated one above.
@ dr hemant sant : You have no right to talk about others faith which is blameless and which has enough proof and when you are so stupid to trust soemone who has molested Kids and ruined thier innocence and Lives. And I don not think any one forced you to watch Kate Williams Wedding

This is good work Vishal.

I come from a family which prides itself on being staunch "Sai Devotees". From the day I way born, I was told that Baba is God, and for many years I beleved it. I sang Bhajans, went for Nagar Sankirtans, went for Bal Vikas classes, and joined in the activities of the local Sai Samiti.

In 2002, I went to Whitefield for my first real Darshan. I didnt see anything spectacular, but enough to know the difference between truth and farce.

I no longer have any faith in Baba. But I realize that among devotees, to doubt Baba is to commit the greatest of sins. Their faith gives him protection. And now that he is gone, the truth may have gone with him.

Your article may not make people renounce their faith, but as long as it plants the seed of doubt even in one devotee's mind, I guess you task will be done.

Ok you exposed him. So now what? Are you happy?

So are those who recieved the benefits of his unparalled social work

So are those whose minds and souls were healed by reposing immense faith in him. Don't you see him as a psychiatrist and psychologist to all these people.

Ok he enjoyed sexual pleasure. So? How did it make your life worse?

Ok he did magician tricks. So? How did it make your life worse?

Understandably, Vishal got to make his livelihood, some fame, by means of this article. So thank him Vishal and move on. :)

Maybe some people lincluding governers politicians sportsmen and commoners are gullible. Is it any of your business?

Live and let live and enjoy what you have. Dont be so envious.

Excellent work Vishal. I have some interest in religious studies and have had the priveledge of studying the greatest scriptures available on this earth. Like Bible, Geeta, Guru Granth Sahib, Koran, some vedas & shastras as well. One truth, which can be extratcted from these scriptures, people should realise is that a true messenger or a true divine does not need to propagandise his teachings. So people who fall prey to such baba's and so called holy saints, should read the great scriptures available on this earth to understand how these scriptures never propagandise the gurus, messengers, divine lights. etc. Guru Granth Sahib says that there are three kinds of religious messengers on this earth: 1) Who have experienced the divine on this earth and are able to spread the message across. They are pure and believe in supreme and are not biased. Examples: Guru Nanak, Krishan, Ram, Buddha, Mahavira, Prophet Mohammed, Jesus Christ. Shiva, etc. (basically all avatars) also holy sufi saints like Hafiz, Bulley Shah, Kabir, etc. Note: none of them ever claimed to be god. Even they themselves performed samadhis and offered prayers to God/the Almighty. 2) Who have experienced the divine on this earth but could not say anything much about them. Even they are considered pure and believed in supreme and are were not biased. Examples: Swami Ramkrishna Paramhansa. Note: His teachings were spreaded by Swami Vivekanand. 3) Who have NOT experienced the divine on this earth BUT are SELLING messages, claiming themselves to be spiritual gurus, saints and GOD. Guru Granth Sahib calls these people TRADERS OF SPIRITUALISM/RELIGION. Examples: Sathya Sai Baba, Nirankaris, etc. ( I don’t need to say more, examples are pervasive). So friends please read teachings/scriptures/biographies of these great souls, and you will find that they never mentioned anything about themselves or narrated anything about themselves or to some extent they mentioned of themselves as NONE or MINISCULE (I am not able to find better words), because they got lost so much in the bliss of divine and merged themselves as one with him but luckily enough they worked across to spread the message to enlighten people like us. Clearly, when such great souls mentioned in human history did not call themselves a GOD, instead offered prayers by themselves to GOD, then how can a human being called Sathya Sai Baba claims to be a GOD himself? It is like after Sathya Sai Baba’s death we may have to live without GOD, or before his birth world was without a GOD. Know thy GOD!

You have identified the truth, but then how do you nail it? People like Sai Baba are able to manipulate people to create wealth and then abuse this wealth to manipulate the system. It is a self serving circle that is completed with the aid of many powerful people who realise the truth, but abet it instead as they need the show to go on. It is a world run by Money and Fame. It is a pity that the hundreds, possibly thousands of young men and women sexually abused by the so called mystic, guru, god will never be able to find justice. That all of this has happened in this era is a shame to our society. There is a significant body of evidence that explains how Sai Baba produces things through petty magician's starter tricks and how he has repeatedly abused young boys, men and women. It is a pity that all of this body of evidence will add up to little. It is time we demand the highest propriety and transparency from institutions such as these instead of bow and fall flat in the expectation of salvation.

Love & Selfless Service should be the motto. Whether Sai Baba is GOD or not God is irrelevant. What is important is being a PERFECT STUDENT rather than judging somebody through media reports. Sai Baba is not forcing you to be his devotee. He is just a plain medium just like Christ, Krishna, Rama etc who are called AVATARS, the first human being to become self realised. All human beings have divinity latent in them and its the job of the AVATAR or Perfect Master like SHIRDI SAI BABA to show us the way. Our EGO which has developed through multiple incarnations carries a lot of SANSKARAS and that determines our attitude towards life & GOD-MEN. So GET A LIFE brother, and stop judging people. Let's all MIND OUR OWN BUSINESS of following the TEN COMMANDMENTS. You don't need GOD for it, you just need a SPIRITUAL MENTOR just like in Real Life for our Material needs.

Sathya Sai Baba does not roughly translate in to 'real' but 'Truth'.

Man needs God and Guru to be able to say Sorry..Please...and Thank You for events that he thinks he she has no controll over..Ramdas Shankara all said God is in goodness in you..your behavior actions..Chidananda rupah shivo ham..Christians have got all humane values right except Your concept of God his son and ''ghosts'' all medievial still clinging to old books..The marriage vows and speech we billions heard at kate William wedding showed Universal values of living and marriage that Christianity shares with us all..esp vedic truth which supposes No God No Guru..path showers..direction givers cannot become destination..Sad GURU is he she who simplifies the complicated..We all human beings will one day find this One in whole and whole in each One Vedic truth..till then avoid bitterness..Faith moves mountains..albiet in wrong directions in some..allow..medium is not important the destination is all paths lead to thee..without pure gyna truth diretion your Boat will never each the Proper port of universal one ness..

very well written. what i like is the balancing part, but still you could have added the work he did for the destitute and many others. He was not god. he was a human like us, but i guess accusations need evidences to be proven. Like the murder charges, devotees turning hostile and being child molester may be true and also it may be true that the government there has played down these issues. but a counter argument can be that other people who stash money in the name of god are the ones who conspired and planted these stories, so the money being donated to the baba comes to them. THE ARGUMENTS WILL NEVER END. But what cannot be argued is the fact that he helped many children getting educated. Many ill were cured in the free hospitals. the donations went back to small villages giving them electricity and water supply. he worked better than our government in short span. Itna karne ke baad saamne se mango to people would kill themselves, children who would have lived on streets and become criminals in future would have said molest me but educate me free so that i can change my future. AUR KYA CHARGES HAI BATAU TO ???

Anyways thank god! the god died. when is he coming back? After 100 years this time? Cant see one more pervert like this getting worshiped anymore

Nice Article..

How can you identify whether the so called ‘miracle’ (if they are not black magic) that you see comes from God or Evil (personified by Satan)?

God has given free will to humans. So human beings can choose to follow Him or the Evil. The humans, in the pursuit of God, may be cheated into believing the Evil for God unless they know the real attributes of God and the real attributes of Evil. Understand that Evil also has the same agenda as GOD: to gather the human souls to themselves.

One should remember that Satan and his dominions (devils and demons) are second only to God in power. Evil domain wields significant power in this material world. Evil also possess power to sway the human soul ultimately to cheat them and to make them feel empty.

First and the foremost attribute of GOD is that He is Holy. Evil is unholy. This is the one significant difference. When you see miracles, but not holy life behind the miracles, then those miracles are not from God.

One thing I notice in this article is that a teaching of Jesus was taken out of context by Dr Naresh K Bhatia. Jesus said if you look at a woman with lust, you have already committed adultery. He was saying that you should not only commit adultery with your body, but also not with your mind and thoughts. This is the holiness that God expects of human beings (and Jesus came to impart this holiness and righteousness to humans through his sacrifice...)

From the article, I do not see any trace of divine holiness in the main character portrayed by Vishal in this article. He is just another human being who pursued his ego and manipulated the BITE (behaviour, information, thoughts, and emotions) of his innocent followers to achieve personal fame and wealth, but he should be given credit for managing his money well to help some of the poorest of poor in India.

People are harping on his social services. Social Services and Hospitals - a cover up action when accusations mounted on him. Money spent is may be less than 1 % of his donation box collections. Services at hospitals were offered by gullible doctor fraternity. He helped Bachchans or Sachins so that he could stay in lime light. Majority of his contributors are highly corrupt government officials and black-money holders.

Baba could not resist his temptation for hair dyes. He wanted to tell his gullible sheep like followers that he would live on forever with no changes. His followers did not see the wrinkles. Did not mind his confinement to a wheel chair. There must have been a puddle of black dye when he was washed for the last time. He has thrown enough dye into the eyes of all his followers.

It is a good article. It seems that the so called GOD uses his retinue and followers to shield his actions and force people who try to contradict him or challenge him

Excellent Article

It is the real eye opener . This is called a psychological control by various moves. Infact the subconscious of a human is not difficult to control when he himself loses the locus of control and same is being done by God man. Vishal ji I congratulate you for your best efforts

Gr8 article indeed!!! what's true and what's not was best known to the" Godman" himself .... lets put an end to it now as he is no more. Lets all be human enough to let his soul in peace because we also do the same to the people we hate the most..... at lest he has done some good for humanity. Remember the best and leave the rest

Please publish this artical in news paper and media, so spread a truth.

Thnaks...

Great article !

This article is 'eye opener' for those who already do not believe in this so-called godman. But those who believe him do not accept anything that you explain to them. only the true god can open their eyes. Vishal and i are afterall human beings who can't do miracles to make these fool people know the truth.

Even if god descend from heaven and tell that he is god, satans are always there to raise their voice of negativity. Gravitational force is there even before all humans and as we cant see that force, like wise these so called new age satans dont see the basic humanity first, leave alone divinity.

Indians lost their mind, we have come through Premanantha, Nithyananda, even though we will not learn, Again we will fell in the feet of great magician. I pity u India, even prime minister n president are falling on his feet, then how can expect a normal citizen to behave, shame shame on u people

Article is highly biased. I don't believe in puttapathi sai baba being god but I have heard and read aobut good work he has done for poor in his village. Hi article focusses on keywords that christians should not follow any hindu religion and gods. As far as I know all churches in India spread the same thing. There walls are scribbled with writings spreading mesage of hate instead of peace. This is not correct. Whatever he may be but his teachings only spread peace and brought people of all religion together. So no offences mr arora ..but your article looks to me more of anti hindu then pro christian then of any other value. Any how dudes like you have spoiled indian culture and whatever your % is in India, should leave India and settle abroad if you dont like India. People like you are really afraid of changes and are against freedom of expression specially spiritual one since you are not able to understand it neither comprehend it as your wisdom lies in your body parts that are below neck

it is amazing how a thug like him blinded so many people ? HATS off to our indian answer to Houdini.Ifail to understand why the so called RATIONAL STRATA of people have such a feeble voice to such act of abuse & deceit & what not?No wonder this can only happen in India.No ANNA HAZARE can deliver anything when we have such a 'NAPUNSHAK' INTELLIGENTIA in this country.this DESH is free for all - politicians,godmen,power brokers,JUGARUS - u are most welcome to plunder and loot this country and people.WE,INDIANS HAVE LEARNED NOTHING FROM HISTORY. THERE IS SO MUCH IN OFFER TO U,PLEASE COME AND LOOT US.WE DO'T HAVE ANY SHAME,ANY MEMORIES.

all this is false...sexual allegations r false.people can claim miracles r false but u cant claim miraculous healings as false...i ve seen a quadriplegic being healed by baba n many terminally ill cancer patients being healed...i m a dr n i ve checked their reports before n after the healings n i m testimony to the fact that the healings have taken place in the blink of an eye....only god can do that.

The Chennai Function photo is illuminating. You have Karunanidhi - a leading member of DMK which was based on athesim, decidely anti-Brahmanic and against all superstitious practices, prevalent in the our society, siting with Sai Baba. I would love to get into Karunanidhi's head to know what he was thinking at this time.

What surprises me is that how did he attract people like AB Vajpayee, PV Narsimha Rao, APJ Abdul Kalam - what brought them there - what did he have that they wanted.

One of my relatives, an aunt, got electrocuted by the olden water heaters at Puttaparthy - not sure if it was personal or communal. She left behing two young children who are quite old now. But the consolation that was aired and still aired was that she would go straight to heaven.

I could never understand the logic. But the questions remains: why did you and I not believe in him? If there is god and he comes in front of me, will I believe him. Will you?

ekdam faltu he..

There is this dude called Vishal Arora who writes articles about “religion and politics in India.” He is a fundamentalist Christian, but will go to great lengths to hide his Christian identity from the readers by using a Hindu name. His modus operandi is to do hit jobs on Hindu saints under the garb of investigative journalism and throw dirt on them in the hope that some of it will stick. All Hindu saints are under attack from this mafia in similar fashion all over India and abroad. This guy approached Sathya Sai Baba’s office for a “quote” about the alleged sex-abuse scandal involving the ashram. The propaganda about this so-called “scandal” is being driven exclusively by evangelical Christians from the US through “ex-devotees” — Xians who were infiltrated into the ashram with a purpose, just like that Christian who “exposed” Swami Nityananda. The modus operandi is similar in both the cases — notice how new “witnesses” appear every day in the Nithyananda scandal to give sleazy tales about him.

greatest article ever...... except its n open truth dat he ws a paedofile. tragic hw v hv to even be made aware of nother side of him...... oh n ya totally believable dat he conjures up those things out of thin air..... why not :))

Gr8 article. I just shows the pic minute by minute. deepti, try to understand he is drawing a true experienced pic, every one can see this pic and see behind. He is not making any allegations. Why you angree then? I know thses Sai devotees who loose temper just because they can say follow any irrational things, but dont want to listen or read not suited to them. may be millions have got mind, whi are sai devotees but are you saying there are billions who lost their mind not to trust a fraud man and call him a fraudster

he has to be to highest tax payer looking at the huge collection of donations in cash and kind poured by blind followers.

Rajesh Ramavarupa has to be pitied. It is a fact that people can become inducted into a doctrine about all the things he mentions - it addles the brain more and more over time and escape becomes almost impossible to those who have invested so much, including hopes, in a massive fraud. Sai Baba's social works are done by his followers, not himself - are nothing special at all. Far from Divine. Many European health services, free education to the highest level are far better than anything anywhere in India. The social care in European countries is supreme by comparison. I was also deceived for close on a couple of decades until the massive wave of sex abuse allegations broke. I am a very reliable source - I met Sai Baba many times, had long interviews and 5 private (together with my wife). I knew some of his most trusted servitors - including the famous editor V.K. Narasimhan, who told me about the 1993 murders and how the police were blackmailed to execute 4 intruders (all devotees) by Sai Baba's younger brother (after a long stand-off in which Sai Baba himself was repeatedly conferring with his staff and the police. But devotees were carefully insulated from the facts about all this, and the Indian government itself has been deeply involved as so many of its top people have embarrassingly long been feet-kissing devotees of Sathya Sai Baba. See my extensive coverage of all aspects of Sathya Sai Baba at http://www.saibaba-x.org.uk/

Seeing is Believing - is a well-known saying.. Only when one has seen the wrong doings of these saints, can one believe & be firmly convinced of the Truth... " You can fool some of the people all the Time, " You can fool All the People Some of the Time, HOWEVER, You Cannot Fool ALL The People ALL the Time...

The allegations of Sai Baba's misdeeds are fairly well known because of various media articles in the past and the BBC documentary. This article brings nothing new - no new facts, allegations, perspectives - to the table. The author finds it hard to fathom the irrationality of believers of Sai Baba. How could they one one hand believe that he could be up to mischief and on the other hand believe that he is God? How could people be conned into believing such nonsense?? For answers to these questions the author needn't look far. The author states that he is a christian. How a believer in a religion chock-full of ridiculous beliefs - virgin birth, jesus raising from the dead and such - could be so impatient with irrational beliefs of people of another religion, is what is so surprising to me. Hypocrisy!

Nice article to open the eyes of a common man..sai baba is an illusionist in real. So he shoud not compare himself to God..

nice one good job vishal

Eye-Opening Article. Well Done !

sai baba is a total dick, there's no two doubts about that. and those who believe in him should go lick his ass

Very nice Article

The article on Sai Baba is thought provoking and interesting. The man who performed so-called miracles for others himself got admitted in hospital for operations earlier. I read an article by magician P.C Sarkar Jr, who went to sai ashram to challenge his miracles. He managed to meet him. When saibaba bought some article from nowherre with sleight of hand, the magician did the same and gave bengali sweet Rosagulla to him. Then the inevitable happened. He was thrown out of the ashram. Earlier Abraham Kovoor the rationalist from srilanka requested to offer rupees one lakh, if he could produce pumpkin from thin air . Ofcourse this challenge was ignored. Your magazine true to your long traditions exposed these godmen and otherr superstitions periodically. If it creates some doubt among the scpetics of sai baba admirers, you have achieved your purpose. Spirituality is a big business and saibaba is one of them. K.S.Sundaram

Leave comment

  • Use to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.